Lilly Penelope
General Information
Gender: Female
Hair Color: Ginger
Eye Color: Brown
Sexuality: Straight
Address: Lima, Ohio
Occupation(s): Student
Family & Friends
Family: Unknown parents
Relationships: Carlton Ayers (Crush)
Friends: Carlton Ayers

The Sensational Singers

Other Information
Interests: Singing, acting
Education: St. Francis de Sales Catholic High School
Vulnerabilities: Is shy, boys
Creator: Jgal12
Series Information
First appearance: Break Up
Last appearance: Duets, Part 1
Portrayer: Hannah Mclalwain
Lilly Penelope is a recurring character on Glee: The Unitards. Lilly is mentioned in Spying to be a rich girl who had only just moved to Defiance, and began attending St. Francis de Sales Catholic High School. She created The Sensational Singers, the school's glee club, and became the lead singer of the club. In Break Up, it is revealed after meeting Carlton, that she had had a crush on him for a very long time, but her heart was broken when he had told her he was gay. This led her to becoming enemies with him. When she returns, she becomes close friends with Carlton once again, but only because she still loves him. In A Win? she competed against The Unitards and Vocal Adrenaline at the 2012 Sectionals, her glee club coming in true third place, but second due to Vocal Adrenaline being disqualified. In Duets, Part 1, Lilly meets with Carlton and gives him a piece of her mind. She is angry at him for lying and cheating at Sectionals by having Jesse as a secret mentor. He apologises, and admits that he was going to steal her Sectionals setlist. They make amends in their friendship.

Later, Lilly re-appears in Reunited where she auditions for the Jackson High concert and reunites with friend Carlton.

Lilly makes appearances in the episodes Break Up, A Win?, Duets, Part 1 and Reunited. It is unknown whether she will return for future episodes in Season Two, but Jordan has revealed that she most likely will return in the future in Season Two at a competition.

Lilly is portrayed by Glee Project Season One contestant, Hannah Mclalwain, and was created by Gleekfan101, the show's creator and writer.


Season OneEdit


Solos In A Group NumberEdit

Song Title Original Artist Sung With Episode Title
Gangnam Style PSY Tommy, Rex, Nick, Justine, Freddie, Simon, Brittany and Amanda Reunited
Rolling in the Deep/Toxic


Carlton, Poppy, Brittany, Liz, Phoebe and Harmony


  • Before her sophomore year (before the season's commencement), Lilly was involved in a few Broadway shows.
  • Originally, Lilly's school was going to be named either St. John's, or West High instead of the current name.

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.